In regards to the recent policy change at D'Angelo library:
As a former resident of BJ, and a former regular user of D'Angelo
library, I would hope that the law school will provide a better
explanation for this change in policy. I have a few questions and
concerns that I would like to see addressed by those who have created
this policy.
First, I may be incorrect, but I do not believe any other library that
stores a large portion of non-law related materials (fun fact: Seasons
2 and 3 of Battlestar Galactica on DVD are at D'Angelo) has a similar
policy. As I recall, Crerar only allows medical students on the 2nd and
3rd floors after regular hours, but even during regular hours all
students have full access. Thus, I would like to know why the law
school believes this policy is necessary, and why D'Angelo is
different from all the other large study spaces on campus.
Furthermore, though this was several years ago, while D'Angelo was
busy during finals and reading period, it never seemed overly crowded.
At least, not crowded enough to warrant the barring of any non-Law
school students to use the study space. This raises the possibility
that students who used to study regularly at D'Angelo will now have
to study at other libraries, making them even more crowded, which hurts
College students and other graduate programs. Thus, I would like to
know if D'Angelo has been seeing increased usage over the past few
years, and if so, of what proportion of the increase are non-law school
students. Hopefully, this will also address how many non-law school
students who used to study in D'Angelo will now be seeking space in
the other libraries. Also, I would like to know how crowded D'Angelo
has been during reading period and finals week compared to the other
libraries.
Furthermore, if D'Angelo can set this precedent, is it possible for
Crerar to also bar students during reading period and finals week?
While I appreciate that D'Angelo will make sure that all books are
still accessible to non-law school students at the reference desk,
there is still a hassle involved in trekking all the way over to
D'Angelo, and then having to immediately return to another library.
This, however, does not address the issue of any books that are on
short reserve times nor books that cannot be checked out.
Finally, I am curious how D'Angelo has the jurisdiction to actually
bar non-law school students from a library where many regular
circulation books are stored. If these are regular books that my
college tuition went towards (or the tuition of any non-law school
student), and if any of non-law school tuition went towards the
library's upkeep, then my peers and I should be able to have access
to it.
While the law school may be within their right to enact this new
policy, I believe many questions need to be answered, some of which I
hope I've raised with my comments above.
By now I'm sure readers have seen the emails from the Law School Dean of Students posted to the SG blog. Unlike Regenstein or Crerar, access to the D'Angelo Law Library is controlled by the Law School, and we have to abide by the rules they set.
This being said, any non-Law student who needs access to the library collections, or would like to consult a reference librarian, will be admitted to the building. My understanding is that you only need to state the purpose of your visit to the VCA (the security guard on the first floor) and he/she will let you in. We want to make sure that
all students and faculty can use Library materials and services during this time.
[UPDATE: The Crerar staff inform us that all floors of Crerar, not just the first floor, are open to all students when the Crerar All Night Study Space is open.]